Once a Cheater Always a Cheater

True or False?  Is it possible the answer could be both?  I think so.  I do believe some people out there will always take the opportunity to cheat and not think twice.  They can’t commit or tell the truth to save their life.  However, I do think some people out there make a huge mistake that may be out of character for them.  Afterward, the shame and guilt is enough to keep them from ever making that same mistake again.

So, how do you tell the difference?  I think looking at the overall character of a person and their past track record is important.  As some of you may know, I’m an avid reader.  Right now I’m reading a book by Anita Shreve called “Testimony”.  The basic plot of the book is that three teenage boys, who are eighteen years or older, have sex with a fourteen year old girl at their boarding school.  Someone else videotapes the incident, and the book is about the fall out of being caught.

Cover of "Testimony: A Novel"

Cover of Testimony: A Novel

Two of the three boys are very different in character.  One boy, James, is known for getting into trouble in the past.  He was already expelled from one school and is trying to finish up one more year in order to get into college.  He likes attention and expects things to come easy for him.  The other boy, Silas, appears to be reliable overall.  He has been awarded a scholarship and works hard at school.  He is also a great athlete.  He has never gotten into trouble and has a long term girlfriend.

After they get caught the story goes on to narrate from each person’s perspective.  Silas is very distraught and ashamed.  He feels horrible about ruining his future and hurting his girlfriend.  He realizes now that one night can erase all the hard work and energy you’ve put in for years.  He is very remorseful and is determined to learn from his mistake.  James blames the victim and doesn’t take any responsibility.  He minimizes the incident and believes everyone is making too big of a deal out of it.  He doesn’t admit he is part of the problem, so he is less likely to change.

If this book wasn’t fiction I would bet money in Vegas that Silas would never cheat again and James would.   As a reader it is easier to feel sorry for and forgive Silas than James, even though both boys did something horrible.  This isn’t always true in real life.  Sometimes it is hard to tell who really feels sorry and won’t do it again, and who is still lying even after getting caught.  I do think that actions speak louder than words.  This is usually the only way you can know if someone is being honest.  Anyone can apologize and swear they will never do it again.  Only a few can actually follow up those words with actions that show you they really are sorry and want to prove to you it will never happen again.

If you’ve been cheated on, I suggest looking at all the other things in your relationship to tell you whether you think they will do it again.  Has this person treated you well for the most part in your relationship?  Are they respectful of you and give you their time and attention when you need it?  How are they with other people in general?  Can you count on them for other things in your relationship?  Do they follow through with what they say they are going to do?  If the answer is no, it could mean the cheating is just the tip of the iceberg.  If you have a lot of other issues in your relationship, the cheating could be only one symptom of many things wrong in your relationship.   If the answer is yes, it may be worth it to give them another chance.  If this act was completely out of character for them and your relationship seems to be pretty stable otherwise, then there may be hope.

Sometimes people aren’t aware of what they are capable of.  I’ve heard some people say they would never cheat.  However, the right situation mixed with certain emotions can put anyone in danger.  None of us is perfect.  Once it’s happened to someone it makes them more aware.  They may choose to not put themselves in certain situations with a false sense of security.  Pain and loss are the toughest teachers.  Some of those lessons are never forgotten.  Seeing how their actions can really hurt and effect others can be enough to make some people a lot more careful in the future.  This makes it possible to build trust back.

Then there are the people that don’t take responsibility in the first place.  They blame someone else or they minimize everything.  They say to themselves and everyone else, “It was only one time.  It wasn’t that big of a deal.  It didn’t mean anything.  I was drunk.  He or she came on to me.”   All those are excuses.  I love when people say, “It didn’t mean anything”.  Like that is helpful.  Something that doesn’t mean anything isn’t hurtful!  The act of cheating does mean something, and it can help build trust back in the relationship if the person who cheated can figure out what led up to it.  Even if it is just to discover how vulnerable they are in certain situations or when they feel certain emotions.   If someone doesn’t know why it happened in the first place or blames someone else, how can they promise it will never happen again?  They can’t!!  The person who can’t own up to it has a greater chance of lying to you again in the future.

Anyone who chooses to stay with someone after they have cheated is taking a risk.  Sometimes it works out and sometimes it doesn’t.  You aren’t stupid for giving someone another chance.  Only time will tell, and if they hurt you again, you have the choice to leave at that point.  No one else can tell you when it’s the right time to leave a relationship.  Everyone is different, and most circumstances are different.  Trust your instincts.  I do believe in my heart that once a cheater, always a cheater isn’t always true.  So, try to look at the relationship as a whole to help you decide if you want to stay or go.

10 comments on “Once a Cheater Always a Cheater

  1. Correction; Anyone who choses to be in a love relationship is taking a risk. Can we minimizes the chances that others will hurt us or that bad things will happen to us, Yes & no. We can’t change or control other’s behavior. What we can do is change ourselves. How to avoid getting cheated on is about learning how to not feel hurt/betrayed/traumatized by cheating (and seeing it as something that will likely “happen” to all of us, whether we know it or not). We need to learn how to not personalize it, and we can learn how to reframe it. The human impulse toward freedom and novelty in our sexual relationships is just as strong as our need for security and bonding (it’s not a “bad people cheat/good people don’t” issue. Managing that paradox is the issue. Just based on plain numbers, if you buy the research, cheating among animals and humans is normative behavior (that might not sound nice, but it’s the truth, and likely always has been). Rather than continue to fight against that, why don’t we figure out how to live in this reality and let go of our rigid need for sexual monogamy. Read the books, Sex at Dawn & Mating in Captivity for a deeper analysis of these issues.

  2. Pingback: Relationships And Cheating How To Get Over It | Get Ex Back

  3. Pingback: My Ex Thinks I Cheated | Making Up Made Easy

  4. Well my girlfriend has cheated on her exs before and she cheated on me while she was drunk but it wasn’t sex related. Her ex took advantage through text and got some pics and I told him straight out that his move f**ked him over and he hasn’t talked to me since but he is like barley talking to her cuz of it.

    • Maybe it’s a good thing he isn’t talking to her anymore. Hope it all works out for you and your girlfriend. Thanks for your comment.

  5. I just cheated on my girlfriend and I never ever thought that it was possible for me to do this and always despised guys that did. It is so true that ”the right situation mixed with certain emotions can put anyone in danger.” It caught me out big time, it is very hard to explain and I will regret it for the rest of my life. I confessed & apologised profusely to her but she couldnt accept it and Ive now lost the best thing thats ever happened to me. It seems that I had to learn this catastrophic lesson the hard way though as it is now welded into my brain and will stop me from being in a compromising situation ever again, the pain is just too great.
    My biggest wish right now is that I had a time machine…

    Thanks for this well written article, it helped in some way to reconcile.

    • Thanks so much for sharing your story! I really appreciate your honesty. I’m sorry that you lost your relationship over it, but hopefully things will work out for you in the future. Take care of yourself!

  6. Thank you for this article! The reason why I decided to look up this topic and comment was because my boyfriend and I were having issues way before he left for BCT (army basic training). I repetitively told him that this whole long distance endeavor wasn’t going to work out and that I got some bad feelings about it. I asked him to stay and not go. He didn’t listen to me and left me, but we still spoke over letters every two weeks or so.. In the end, after being stuck at home for a month or two in bed being all down and upset, never leaving my room, friends finally forced me to go out and have a good time at parties. One thing led to another and terrible things occurred. I had cheated on him, without intentionally seeking to hang out with any guys. I felt awful but I had to tell him. It was going to haunt me forever. It was going to damage us every time I was with him. It was a terrible time. He has been gone for 8 months after all. Once I told him, things broke, but we got stronger. He finally stopped being a self absorbed douche bag (sorry but he was…) and got down and serious about us, probably realizing that he was going to lose me or so he implied in our long conversations. Deep down, I know he is still hurt and the scar will always be there on each of us. Now that we’re closer than ever before (probably due to the distance), I can’t help but wonder about the saying, “Once a cheater always a cheater.” I always hated knowing about couples cheating on each other but I now understand there are certain situations. Because of what happened, I learned I had stronger feelings for him than ever and knew he was the right guy after that (the one I wanted from the beginning – we had only been together for 9 months, 3 of which he was away when the cheating occurred). I know trust is the most important thing each party has to possess for each other and for themselves to make the relationship work/last. Yet, I don’t trust myself and I do almost everything to keep myself from hanging out with male friends (unless they are gay), including drinking, going out, and various other activities (even if they have a girlfriend). My Love trusts me completely, which is insane of him after what I did. It’s college after all and that terrifies me more. However, this article relieved a few stress points and acknowledged the fact that I need to trust myself a little bit more in order for things to work for a long time. It’s one of the things plaguing my mind. Thank you and sorry for the story!

    • Thanks so much for the comment! I appreciate you sharing your story. I’m glad you feel a little bit better. Good luck in the future!!

I would love to hear what you think about this post or about my blog in general. Also, feel free to leave any suggestions or ideas for new posts in the future! Thanks!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s